tBlog - Taboo Monkey Blue Blog: Writing on Writing

The Untouchable Taboo

Taboo's critical literary discussions about Ernest Hemingway, Hermann Hesse, T.S. Eliot, Flannery O'Connor, Franz Kafka, and many other authors. Links to full story texts and critical discussions.


Blog For Free!


Archives
Home
2008 June
2007 April
2007 March
2007 February
2007 January
2006 December
2006 October
2006 July
2006 June
2006 May
2006 April
2006 March
2006 February
2006 January
2005 November
2005 October
2005 February
2005 January
2004 December

My Links
Home
TaBoo's Ezine Navigator
The Greatest Maze
Sudoku Tips and Tricks
Joe User
The Phallic Suggestion

tBlog
My Profile
Send tMail
My tFriends
My Images


Sponsored
Blog



The Untouchable Taboo
02.06.06 (9:34 am)   [edit]

Sometimes you get to a place in your life where all those assumptions--what is right, what is wrong--must be called into question.

You leave your parents. You leave your home town. You learn something about a loved one that you didn't want to hear. The foundations of your life move farther and farther away, and now YOU must make your way forward, or not. You must find a way to do what is right. Or not. In your isolation, you are Untouchable. No one else shares responsibility with you. No one takes your part.

The hardest part is the weeding that you must do. You must weed through what your parents told you was right; you must weed through your apprehension of punishment, searching yourself for what it is that you believe. Year by year, you grow less assailable. Fewer and fewer people can legitimately hold you accountable for your actions. Is there a god? Perhaps your god holds you accountable for your actions. The Testaments brim with "do theses" and "don't do thoses," all the while suggesting that humanity itself is incapable of determining right from wrong on its own.

None of that changes this simple fact: confronted with a choice, when deciding right from wrong, you stand alone, by yourself, with only your reason, your heart, your soul, your desire to guide you.

For some time now, for various reasons of heart and soul and desire, I have wanted to write down My Rules. Let's suppose for the moment that there is a right, and there is a wrong. Let's suppose I can figure out the difference. At a moment of choice, if I knew the Truth, if I knew what was right, what was wrong, would I choose to do what was right?

Sometimes, I imagine. Even most of the time, perhaps. If always I knew the difference, then I would no longer have the best of all excuses: there is no right decision. Both are evil. Everything is nothing but a shade of grey.

But if I knew the right and the wrong, always, if always I knew the difference, then I would still choose wrong, if only some of the time.

My Rules--as they currently exist as a flow of blood from my heart to my gut to my brain and then into bone and muscle and action--aren't Truths. They are compromises between what I believe at a given moment, and what I want to believe.

Goethe wrote, "I've never heard of a crime that I could not imagine committing myself."

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

 

 

 

This is a strange Truth--it frightens us to think that we might have the same capacity to create harm as those people throughout history who we deem abhorrent, evil, Untouchable.

 

 

 


It is easier to believe that we are innocent of others' wrongdoings. It is a seductive fantasy to believe we are innocent until proven guilty.

When choosing between right and wrong, sometimes the decision appears to be a simple one. Usually the choice is complex, with ripples of consequences that play out through space and time.

Consider these abstract "right" choices: faith, honesty, self-sacrifice, patience, love. Suppose you make a choice for faith, for honesty, for another human being through an act of self-sacrifice, if you fight despair with patience, if you combat isolation and envy and anger with love--suppose those are your Rules, then what happens when they conflict?

In the name of faith or fear, it is written that Abraham intended to sacrifice his son. And who is wise enough to see the right path, when the honest dictates of your heart tells you that you love someone you should not? Is it Right to sacrifice Self and Honesty, to give up your Truth, to withhold your honest word in order to preserve Order? If I love her, and I shouldn't, shall I speak or remain silent?

I can't withhold. I can't act. But I can't shut it down. Nothing answers the pain. Nothing helps, not hope, not breath, not the Lie, not the Truth. A Book of Rules I compose over and over in my heart dissolves endlessly into dust, and I keep thinking that I can hold on to things that feel right if I don't forget them. Everything that ever meant anything to me, I lose, because I cannot choose.

My Book of Rules had dwindled to five generic Rules. This weekend I broke each of my five in the name of another of the five.

Dedication.

Empathy.

Intention.

Gentleness.

Love.

I'm looking for new Rules. I've gathered two: if not integrity, then honesty. If not dedication, then hope.


Taboo's Ezine Navigator: Article Index
Taboo Tenente
Copyright ©2004, ©2005, ©2006 Joshua P. Suchman.

 


posted by: graceshaker (reply)
post date: 02.06.06 (9:34 am)

i think you may enjoy soren kierkegaards book 'fear and trembling'.



posted by: surrogate (reply)
post date: 02.06.06 (4:07 pm)

Of the five you listed, intention is wild card, always. You can always be loving even if you don't or can't love.

Gentleness is a behavioral choice as are dedication and empathy. Intention (and I'm assuming "good" intentions are what you mean here) is the tit in the wringer of life. It' so fluidly etherial and easily manipulated by those other four, that I think it's hard to keep a finger on it, especially in times of stress.

The "one" that seems to be missing from the list might be the one that's giving you all the grief.

(keeping) Promises

When time, circumstances and knowledge cause our feelings to change, are the promises we made to ourselves and others based on what we then thought we knew, to be allowed to dictate our future? And at that new place to which we've just arrived, are the breaking of past promises a sign of bad intentions or good?

I think (and I do mean just 'think') that if you act lovingly and empathetically, showing gentleness and love, that you have to go with assuming that you still have good intentions, even if you must break old promises.

Integrity? Not something we get to ascribe to ourselves.

Hope? Always.

And, of course the upshot of all this? The nasty little joy sucker we end up fighting with even when we oughtn't?

Guilt.

Fuck guilt.




posted by: TaBooTenente (reply)
post date: 02.06.06 (5:57 pm)

surrogate,

some time ago, dedication was fidelity, but it felt too much like the blind version of integrity. dedication seemed like an honest version of humility--dedication to something larger than myself.

intention: there is a hebrew word that is sort of a mixture of the words intention, spirit, focus, and faith: kavana. i've thought about kavana for a long time. it's a zen-like word, but with an identity attached. in some ways, it pre-exists the others that ive listed. but you're right: an incomplete grasp on kavana is easily corrupted. and it doesn't belong on a list of Rules.

the others, at some point, seemed to be distinct from each other: empathy, gentleness, love. i thought empathy implied both the awareness of Other, and also a universal condition of struggle. i thought gentleness implied both humility and perspective. i thought love was the right-minded emotion that made all other goodnesses possible.

promise keeping and guilt are so intertwined, it's like yinyang. two sides of the same thing. faith is a more true incarnation of promise keeping, but when i first considered faith as a Rule, i began to believe that kavana was the true, human incarnation of faith. faith? in jerusalem for the first time, standing before the western wall, i was shocked by how much emotion i felt. i'm not an atheist, but my spiritual beliefs have only a long causal relationship with the jewish tradition to which i was born.

but there was something, and i wont lie: i wont say i know what it was; and i wont say it was nothing. it was something. perhaps it came all from me. but at the moment, at least, that didnt matter.

and then there was a young hasid, a man in his late teens, maybe, praying his ritual prayers, memorized--though he still held his prayer book. he was looking everywhere, eyes focusing on everything, but there was no concentration. i thought: he is addicted to his ritual; this isnt an act of faith.

so felt superior, of course. i knew what i felt was something real, right? i wasn't pretending it was something it wasn't, right?

afterward, i knew i had experienced nothing but the wish to experience something--just as i had wished to feel superior to the distracted young man. i wasn't. and all rituals are in some ways acts of faith. was he praying with kavana? what does it say about my own intention, that i should wonder about his intention?

and that attitude shouldn't be a rule.

guilt and promise-keeping--you are right. both only serve to prevent us from growing--at least when they become rules, or addictions, or blinders on our vision. empathy, gentleness, love--all, i think, are parts of compassion, which is endlessly large, and never forgets either the Self or the Other.

something to work to achieve: a lifelong expression of compassion--

but to get there, i need to be honest with myself and others that it is a journey, not a rule.

and i need hope because life sucks, sometimes. what else can you do? there is nothing worse than hope's alternative.

today, i made myself hope, and through hope i found the courage to be honest.

things are bad. but they aren't as bad as they were.

thank you, surrogate.

taboo




posted by: TaBooTenente (reply)
post date: 02.06.06 (6:01 pm)

grace,

i'm ashamed to say that i took a class as an undergraduate, that included 'fear and trembling'--i didnt read it. so much for dedication and intention.

usually, it's the book i missed that i should have read. it's on the list, now. thanks, grace.

taboo


Your Name:


Your Comment: